I was worried about humidity, you’re not supposed to open it at all and it’s a common breeder mistake that can result in the loss of the eggs. I’m not sure why they’re squishy but it could just be bad eggs. If you see mold apply athletes foot powder to it and it should go away. What are your temperature cycles in your enclosure that you’re incubating the eggs in (eg. 12 hours on 12 hours off)? I would recommend just making an incubator (basic outline here). Do you dust your feeder insects for your geckos, give them a dish of calcium, or give them a uv light?
And until the eggs are definitely not going to hatch keep incubating them as if they are.
Incubate Until There’s No Debate