I agree with both of you.
I would think the best way, and it would still be a mess that would need a dedicated curator (per guide), would be to have the information section at the top, and the discussion in sections below.
My suggestion would be to ask for volunteers, divide the discussion up by section of the guide, and maybe even go so far as to poll the community on the most comon answers.
Ie: this part is for temps and humidity…
This part for size of enclosure and maybe type (land, sea, air)…
This part food and activity behavior…
Etc.
I think these guide pages would be the most useful for the less commonly kept species, and for them, I would think the number of contributors would be naturally smaller, and thus easier to manage.
Just really wish there was a better source for some of this than a one page blog entry on reptiles.com that just copy pastes the information from everyone else.
Even commonly kept species can be a real damn shoot for information. Just go look for a solid and data rich guide for BCI localities, go ahead, I’ll wait… Yeah, got overloaded with it? Me too…
I would love to expand into some of these species, but when the husbandry data consists of “keep them pretty much like…” that’s not good enough. I don’t want to put the animal at risk as I fumble along. And a higher success rate means more keepers for a species, which means more availability/visibility. And that can only be a good thing for the hobby as a whole.
However it ends up, if it ends up, and if the guides turn out to be better than just general slop, then having a link available on the ad for people to tap to access the guide for that species would be awesome sauce.
“I love satanic leaf tail geckos, they look so cool, would love to have a reliable, trustworthy guide handy to access to see if that is a species that I might reasonably add to my huge collection, before I go spend uncounted hours deep diving, researching, calling and pestering keepers…”
“I’m brand new to the hobby, I’m looking to buy my first snake, but I’m down to Brazilian rainbow or kenyan sand, and I can’t decide, maybe a quick click to a guide might tell me that one is better suited to me than another before I get the wrong one and have a terrible experience, turning me and my parents away from the hobby…”
Yeah, “research the animal” is always part of the response I give too. I think the MM community can and should be part of that. We, collectively, have alot of information to offer. I just see this as a way to gather up and consolidate this part.
I hope the guides do happen, I think the MM forum community is sane, civilized, and polite enough to be able to do this as a community without having it devolve into the usual online chaos. When the guides do happen, I hope there’s a link in the marketplace…data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/5a6d6/5a6d64184d5d36417fd483479aae185b0d039faf" alt=":grin: :grin:"